Cricket

Shane Watson Criticises India's Lack of Stability Under Gautam Gambhir

  • Authored By: Sports Now
  • Updated Oct 10, 2026, 07:31 IST

Former Australian all-rounder Shane Watson has questioned India's consistency under head coach Gautam Gambhir, citing frequent changes to the playing XI and batting order as a primary concern for the team's recent performance.

Shane Watson Criticises India's Lack of Stability Under Gautam Gambhir

Former Australian all-rounder Shane Watson has voiced concerns regarding the current state of the Indian cricket team, pointing to a lack of stability as a primary factor behind their recent inconsistent results. Since Gautam Gambhir took over as head coach in mid-2024, the side has experienced a mix of high-profile successes and notable struggles, leading to questions about the team's long-term strategy.

While Gambhir has overseen significant triumphs, including victories in the Champions Trophy and the T20 World Cup, these achievements have been punctuated by disappointing outcomes in other formats. Specifically, India has faced home Test series defeats against New Zealand and South Africa, alongside various setbacks in ODI and T20I cricket, prompting external scrutiny regarding the current management's approach.

Concerns Over Team Selection and Consistency

Speaking on Prime Video’s YouTube channel, Watson highlighted the frequent rotation of players and shifting batting orders as a hindrance to sustained success. According to the former Australian international, the constant adjustments make it difficult for the squad to establish a rhythm, which he believes is essential for maintaining high performance levels across all formats of the game.

Despite these criticisms, Watson was quick to credit Gambhir for his man-management skills. He specifically highlighted the coach's support for wicketkeeper-batter Sanju Samson, noting that the backing provided by the coaching staff allowed Samson to deliver crucial performances during the knockout stages of the T20 World Cup. Watson maintained that while Gambhir has introduced many positive elements to the setup, the team would be significantly more formidable if they prioritized continuity in selection and role clarity for the players.

Recent T20I Setback Against West Indies

The discussion surrounding team stability follows a high-scoring T20I defeat for India against the West Indies in Ranchi. Despite posting a formidable total of 249-5, anchored by an 82-run knock from Sanju Samson off 41 balls, India was unable to defend the target. The West Indies successfully chased the total to win by six wickets, leveling the five-match series at 1-1.

The visitors' victory was driven by a decisive 120-run partnership between Shai Hope, who finished unbeaten on 102 from 45 balls, and Sherfane Rutherford, who contributed 84 from 37 deliveries. The two teams are scheduled to face each other in the third T20I in Indore this Sunday, which will serve as a critical encounter before India embarks on an extensive all-format tour of New Zealand.