Former Pakistan spinner
Kaneria, however, argues that these personnel changes are merely superficial and fail to address the systemic rot within the organization. Speaking to news agency IANS, the former international expressed frustration over the lack of a coherent strategy, questioning the logic behind the current selection committee and the overall direction of the team. He emphasized that the primary issue is a lack of competitive spirit, noting that the team appears to have lost the fighting quality that once defined Pakistan cricket.
Systemic failures and selection concerns
The critique extended to the team's tactical approach and player selection, with Kaneria highlighting a lack of accountability for poor performances. He specifically questioned the inclusion of certain players in the bowling attack, labeling the current options as ineffective and lacking the technical discipline required for international cricket. He pointed to the exclusion of experienced performers like Mohammad Abbas, who previously claimed nine wickets at Lord's, and Noman Ali, as evidence of flawed decision-making.
Kaneria also voiced concerns regarding the batting lineup, expressing disbelief at the dismissals of senior players such as Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan. He suggested that the current reliance on the Pakistan Super League (PSL) to identify talent has come at the expense of a robust domestic structure. According to Kaneria, the decline of Pakistan cricket is directly linked to the erosion of the domestic system, which he believes has stifled the development of a deep and capable talent pool.
Call for structural reform
To reverse the current downward trend, Kaneria has called for a complete overhaul of how the board operates. He advocated for the appointment of a strong, stable selection committee and an experienced coaching staff that is given sufficient time to build a cohesive unit. He noted that the current practice of short-term appointments prevents any meaningful progress or long-term development.
Drawing a comparison to the Indian cricket structure, Kaneria highlighted the importance of prioritizing first-class cricket to ensure players are adequately prepared for the rigors of the international game. Ultimately, he urged the board to move away from PSL-centric selection policies and focus on fostering a culture where players are held responsible for their output. He concluded that while losing is a part of the game, the current lack of effort and visible fight on the field is unacceptable for a team with Pakistan's heritage.
