Cricket

Basit Ali Attributes Pakistan Cricket Decline to Babar-Shaheen Captaincy Rift

  • Authored By: Sports Now
  • Updated Sep 1, 2026, 11:15 IST

Former Pakistan batter Basit Ali claims the internal fallout between Babar Azam and Shaheen Shah Afridi over captaincy has caused long-term damage to the national team, contributing to their recent struggles in international cricket.

Basit Ali Attributes Pakistan Cricket Decline to Babar-Shaheen Captaincy Rift

Former Pakistan batter Basit Ali has pointed to the internal leadership dispute between Babar Azam and Shaheen Shah Afridi as the primary catalyst for the national team’s recent decline. According to Ali, the friction between the two senior players regarding the captaincy created a lasting divide that has severely impacted the squad's cohesion and performance on the international stage.

The comments follow a difficult period for Pakistan, highlighted by a 2-0 series defeat against England, which included a 194-run loss at Lord’s. While the team has faced significant scrutiny for their lack of competitiveness during the tour, Ali argues that the root cause of these struggles predates the current series, stemming from the instability within the leadership structure.

Leadership Instability and Internal Friction

Speaking on the show 'Game Plan', Ali expressed his view that the fallout between the two stars was a turning point for the national setup. He stated that the decision-making process within the team has suffered as a result of the fractured relationship, asserting that Pakistan cricket was effectively ruined the day the conflict over the captaincy became public. Ali suggested that the lingering effects of this dispute remain visible in the team's current environment.

The captaincy saga has been marked by frequent changes since the 2023 ODI World Cup. Babar initially stepped down following a disappointing campaign in India, leading to Shaheen taking over the ODI leadership. However, after a series of poor results in New Zealand, Babar was reinstated, only to be removed again following the team's failure to reach the semi-finals of the 2024 T20 World Cup. Currently, the leadership is split, with Babar captaining the Test side, Shaheen leading the ODI team, and Salman Ali Agha in charge of the T20I squad.

Structural Changes Following England Tour

In response to the team's poor showing in England, the Pakistan Cricket Board has initiated significant changes to the coaching and playing staff. Seven players, including Mohammad Rizwan and Salman Ali Agha, have been sent home. Additionally, Test coach Sarfaraz Ahmed and bowling coach Umar Gul have been removed from their positions, with white-ball coach Mike Hesson set to oversee the team for the final Test in Birmingham.

While Babar remains the Test captain, his personal form has also come under scrutiny. He has not scored a Test century in four years, adding further pressure as the team looks to conclude the England series at Edgbaston. Shaheen, meanwhile, is currently not part of the red-ball setup. The board's recent overhaul reflects the urgency to address the team's ongoing challenges as they attempt to move past a period of significant instability.