NFL

NFL Week 3: Separating Legitimate Contenders from Early-Season Overreactions

  • Authored By: Sports Now
  • Updated Sep 28, 2026, 06:15 IST

As the NFL season hits the three-week mark, we evaluate the validity of early trends, including Brock Purdy's MVP candidacy, the Steelers' resilience, and the surprising success of the Raiders and Browns.

NFL Week 3: Separating Legitimate Contenders from Early-Season Overreactions

Three weeks into the NFL season, the league remains as unpredictable as ever. From the Seattle Seahawks falling to a Marcus Mariota-led Commanders squad to the Buffalo Bills securing a win despite five turnovers, the early results have defied conventional wisdom. With teams like the Chargers and Texans sitting at 0-3 while others scramble to find their identity, it is the perfect time to distinguish between genuine trends and reactionary noise.

Among the most discussed topics is the performance of San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy. Having completed 72.3% of his passes for an average of 263 yards per game, Purdy has tallied nine touchdowns against just one interception. His ability to maintain efficiency despite a depleted wide receiver corps has been remarkable. By tying Steve Young’s franchise record for touchdown passes through the first three games, Purdy has firmly established himself as a legitimate MVP candidate rather than a product of early-season hype.

Assessing Team Trajectories and Coaching Impact

The Pittsburgh Steelers have silenced critics who questioned if their 22-year streak of avoiding a losing season would finally end. After a shaky start to the campaign, the team revamped its offensive line approach and leaned on a dominant 127-yard rushing performance from Jaylen Warren to edge out the Cincinnati Bengals 30-27. While the schedule remains challenging, the Steelers have proven they possess the opportunistic mindset necessary to steal wins, suggesting their streak is far from over.

Meanwhile, the Cleveland Browns have managed a 2-1 record despite inconsistent quarterback play from Deshaun Watson. Much of the credit for this stability belongs to head coach Todd Monken. Despite inheriting a difficult quarterback situation, Monken has maintained control of the locker room and maximized his roster's potential. If the Browns continue to lean on their stellar defense and disciplined coaching, they remain a serious threat in the division, making the praise for Monken’s leadership a grounded assessment rather than an overreaction.

Evaluating Quarterback Situations and Fantasy Outlooks

Elsewhere, the New York Giants face a complex reality following the season-ending injury to Jaxson Dart. While Jameis Winston managed to lead the team to a 12-7 victory over the Tennessee Titans, the win was largely a product of poor weather conditions and a conservative game plan. Expecting Winston to sustain this performance over a long stretch is likely an overreaction; the Giants will almost certainly continue to explore other options at the position.

The Las Vegas Raiders have also surprised many with a 3-0 start under Kirk Cousins. While the team is currently thriving, their upcoming schedule—featuring the Chiefs, Patriots, Bills, and Rams—will provide a much sterner test. Regarding fantasy football, managers should remain patient with players like Isaiah Likely and Malik Nabers despite recent struggles, as the rainy conditions in Week 3 skewed offensive production. Conversely, Jordan Addison remains a high-upside asset, capable of WR1 production should Justin Jefferson face any time on the sidelines.