Other Sports

Selection Controversy Erupts as TTFI Drops Harmeet Desai for Mixed Team World Cup

  • Authored By: Sports Now
  • Updated Nov 19, 2026, 20:03 IST

The Table Tennis Federation of India faces criticism after replacing Harmeet Desai with Manush Shah for the upcoming ITTF Mixed Team World Cup, despite Desai leading in the federation's established points-based selection criteria.

Selection Controversy Erupts as TTFI Drops Harmeet Desai for Mixed Team World Cup

The Table Tennis Federation of India (TTFI) is facing intense scrutiny following a last-minute squad adjustment for the upcoming International Table Tennis Federation (ITTF) Mixed Team World Cup. The tournament, scheduled to take place in Chengdu from November 29 to December 6, will now feature Manush Shah in place of Harmeet Desai, a decision that has sparked significant debate regarding the federation's adherence to its own selection policies.

Under the selection points system introduced by the TTFI in July 2026, Harmeet Desai held a clear advantage over his peer. According to the federation’s internal metrics, Desai accumulated 55 points—comprising 35 points for his fourth-place domestic ranking and 20 points for his world ranking of 102 as of November 2. In contrast, Manush Shah finished with 40 points, derived from a tenth-place domestic ranking worth five points and a world ranking of 45, which contributed 35 points.

Controversy Over Selection Criteria

The decision to bypass the points system has drawn sharp criticism, particularly as the TTFI has historically maintained a rigid stance on its criteria. In previous instances, such as the selection process for the Asian Games in Aichi-Nagoya, the federation strictly enforced the points tally, even resulting in the exclusion of high-profile players like Manika Batra from the main squad. Sources indicate that the points system had been the standard for all three previous editions of the Mixed Team World Cup, making this latest deviation an unprecedented move.

Expressing his frustration, Harmeet Desai stated that he was shocked by the exclusion, noting that he had specifically tailored his schedule to align with the federation's requirements. By prioritizing domestic tournaments over international WTT events to bolster his points tally, he believed he had secured his place in the squad. He also pointed to his recent performance at the Asian Championships in Tashkent, where he secured a bronze medal in mixed doubles alongside Yashaswini Ghorpade, as evidence of his readiness for the team format.

Federation Defends Strategic Shift

While Indu Puri, chairperson of the ad-hoc committee, directed inquiries to the selection committee, an anonymous member of the committee defended the choice. The official explained that the decision was reached unanimously, arguing that the unique nature of the Mixed Team World Cup—where doubles play a critical role—necessitated a departure from the standard points system. The committee highlighted that Manush Shah is currently ranked among the world’s top-six in mixed doubles and holds the highest world ranking among Indian men’s singles players, factors they deemed more relevant for this specific competition.

The final squad for the Chengdu event includes Ankur Bhattacharjee, Payas Jain, Manush Shah, and Manav Thakkar for the men’s team, while the women’s side will feature Diya Chitale, Syndrela Das, Yashaswini Ghorpade, and Sutirtha Mukherjee.