Cricket

India batting coach defends team selection as New Zealand recovers in first Test

  • Authored By: Sports Now
  • Updated Nov 19, 2026, 12:43 IST

India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak has defended the decision to exclude Mohammed Siraj from the playing XI after New Zealand’s middle-order mounted a strong fightback on the opening day of the first Test.

India batting coach defends team selection as New Zealand recovers in first Test

India’s batting coach, Sitanshu Kotak, has publicly defended the team management’s decision to omit pacer Mohammed Siraj from the starting lineup for the first Test against New Zealand. The selection choice faced immediate scrutiny on Thursday after the Indian bowling attack struggled to maintain pressure, allowing the hosts to recover from a precarious position at the Basin Reserve in Wellington.

Despite a dominant start that saw New Zealand reduced to 70/5, the visitors were unable to capitalize on their early momentum. An unbroken 173-run partnership between Henry Nicholls, who finished the day unbeaten on 113, and Glenn Phillips, who reached 94 not out, shifted the balance of the match firmly in favor of the Black Caps, who closed play at 243/5.

Selection strategy under the microscope

Addressing the media following the day's play, Kotak insisted that the team management had carefully evaluated the conditions and the opposition before finalizing the XI. He maintained that there were no underlying issues with Siraj, emphasizing that the selection was based on finding the best possible combination for the specific challenges of the match.

The bowling unit saw Jasprit Bumrah lead the charge with 3/52 from 17 overs, repeatedly testing the New Zealand top order. However, the supporting cast found it difficult to replicate that threat once the new ball lost its shine. Anshul Kamboj, who replaced Siraj, claimed 1/57 from 18 overs, while Prasidh Krishna remained wicketless after conceding 58 runs in 16 overs. Akash Deep provided the only other breakthrough, finishing with 1/33.

Tactical reasoning and performance assessment

Kotak explained that the inclusion of Washington Sundar was a tactical move designed to counter New Zealand’s lineup, which featured four left-handed batters. He further defended the selection of Prasidh Krishna, describing the pacer as an attacking option who is prone to conceding runs while hunting for breakthroughs. According to the coach, the team’s philosophy is to prioritize wicket-taking potential even when it comes at a higher cost.

Reflecting on the day’s play, Kotak acknowledged that India had missed a crucial opportunity to further dismantle the New Zealand middle order, noting that a missed catch involving Rishabh Pant and Devdutt Padikkal had proven costly. While the pitch offered assistance to the seamers early on, the sunny conditions eventually flattened the surface, allowing Nicholls and Phillips to settle in and dominate the latter half of the day. As the match progresses, the Indian side will need to find a way to regain the control they surrendered during the final two sessions.