Former England batting great
The controversy, which became known as
Boycott compares scandal to Hansie Cronje affair
Expanding on his criticism, Boycott made the provocative claim that the Australian ball-tampering episode was more damaging to the sport than the 2000 match-fixing scandal involving former South Africa captain Hansie Cronje. While Cronje was handed a lifetime ban for accepting money from bookmakers to influence match outcomes, Boycott suggests the scale of the Australian incident was fundamentally different due to the collective nature of the involvement.
Boycott argued that while the Cronje case primarily involved a small group of individuals, the Sandpaper Gate scandal implicated a much wider collective. He asserted that the planning and subsequent cover-up involved the broader squad and coaching staff, ultimately resulting in only three players facing formal sanctions. By contrast, Boycott views the Australian team’s coordinated efforts as an unprecedented act of mass cheating that has left a deeper stain on the game’s history.
Following the 2018 incident, Smith served a one-year suspension handed down by Cricket Australia. In his book, Sabr, teammate Usman Khawaja noted that Smith accepted the punishment in part to protect other members of the squad. Despite the passage of time and the completion of the players' bans, Boycott remains firm in his view that history should judge the former captain harshly for failing to prevent the team from engaging in the illicit activity.